Thanksgiving Cocktails

A bitters-forward guide to what to pour across Thanksgiving: aperitifs, fall-flavored classics, cozy warm drinks, and a good no-alcohol option.

November 8, 2026

A spread of fall cocktails on a Thanksgiving table

Thanksgiving is a drinking holiday wearing an eating holiday's clothes. There's the glass while you cook, the one you hand each guest at the door, the toast at the table, and the slow pour once the plates are cleared. You don't need a different cocktail for each, but it helps to have a plan.

Here's what I'd pour, grouped by the part of the day it fits, with a lean toward drinks where a few dashes of bitters do the quiet work. A bittered drink before a big meal is a long-standing aperitif tradition, and bitters are what keep a sweet, boozy holiday drink from tasting flat.

Before the meal

Old Fashioned. The aperitif. Bourbon, a little sugar, a couple of dashes of bitters, and a big cube. It's bitter and spirit-forward, which is exactly what you want in your hand before a heavy plate. If you're pouring one drink all night, make it this.

Black Manhattan. Whiskey, amaro in place of sweet vermouth, and bitters. It's darker and a little more serious than a regular Manhattan, and it suits a cold evening and a long table.

Sazerac. If you want more edge, this is one of the most bitters-forward classics there is, built on Peychaud's bitters and a rinse of absinthe. One is plenty.

The toast

Champagne Cocktail. A sugar cube soaked in bitters, dropped in a flute, and topped with something cold and sparkling. It's the easiest way to make a toast feel like one, and it scales for a full table without a shaker in sight. Soak the cubes ahead and you can pour a dozen in a couple of minutes.

The fall-flavored ones

Maple Old Fashioned. The Old Fashioned with maple syrup in place of the sugar. It tastes like the season, and it's the most natural Thanksgiving pour on this list.

Smoked Old Fashioned. Woodsmoke over the whole drink. It's the showpiece of the night, and it suits the fireplace-and-leftovers stretch of the evening.

Anything with apple bitters. A few dashes turn a plain whiskey drink into something that tastes like a cold night. If you've got a jar going, this is the weekend to use it.

Cozy and warm

A hot toddy. Bourbon, honey, lemon, hot water, and a dash of aromatic bitters. It's the drink for the cold walk to the car or the last mug of the night. Warm the mug first so it stays hot.

Mulled wine or mulled cider. A pot on the stove that fills the house and serves a crowd from one ladle. Red wine or apple cider, warm baking spice, a little sweetener, and citrus, kept warm but never boiled. A few dashes of bitters sharpen either one.

Spiked apple cider. The low-effort crowd-pleaser: warm cider, a pour of bourbon or apple brandy, and a few dashes of apple or aromatic bitters. It's done in the time it takes to heat the cider.

The no-alcohol one

A mocktail with a dash of bitters. Not everyone at the table is drinking, and a glass of juice or soda shouldn't be the only option. A splash of non-alcoholic bitters in soda water or an alcohol-free sparkling wine gives the sober guest a real drink, with the same dry, grown-up edge that keeps a cocktail from tasting like flat juice. (Standard bitters are high-proof, but a dash adds only a trace of alcohol. Here's the math, and an alcohol-free version is there if that matters.)

Making your own

Bitters are in every drink on this list. If you'd rather make them than buy them, that's what the rest of this site is for.

Start with what bitters actually are