The smoked Old Fashioned is the drink that made every craft bar buy a smoking gun. Under the theater, it's a normal Old Fashioned with a layer of woodsmoke. That smoke plays against the caramel of the bourbon and the spice of the bitters in a way that feels like a fireplace in a glass. It's a cold-weather drink, and it's far more doable at home than the bar presentation makes it look.
There are three ways to get smoke into the drink, from no gear at all to a full kit. Pick the one that matches what's in your kitchen.
Three ways to smoke it
- A torch and a piece of wood (the home standard). You char a wood chip or plank with a kitchen torch and trap the smoke in the glass. It's the cheapest real-smoke method, and it does everything the gadgets do. The recipe below uses this one.
- A smoking gun or cocktail smoker lid (the bar method). A handheld smoker pumps smoke under a lid or cloche over the drink. It's cleaner and more repeatable if you make these often, but it's gear you're buying for one trick.
- A smoked ingredient (no gear). Skip the fire and build the smoke into the drink: a small float or rinse of smoky mezcal or peated Scotch, a smoked simple syrup, or a smoked ice cube. It's the easiest way in, and genuinely good.
Why the smoke works
Bourbon already tastes of charred oak, so smoke isn't a foreign note. It's an extension of what's in the glass. A short exposure is all you want, though: enough to perfume the drink, not so much that it tastes like an ashtray. Smoke is a seasoning, same as the bitters, and the drink underneath still has to be a good Old Fashioned.
What you need
Makes one drink.
- 2 oz bourbon. A bold, higher-proof bourbon stands up to the smoke. (Which bourbon to use.)
- 1 teaspoon simple syrup or 1 sugar cube. Maple syrup is excellent here too, if you want a smoked maple version.
- 2 to 3 dashes aromatic bitters. Angostura is the classic. (What bitters do.)
- A large ice cube.
- An orange twist, to finish.
- For the smoke: a small handful of wood chips or a wood plank (applewood, cherry, oak, or hickory) and a kitchen torch. Or a smoking gun or cocktail smoker lid, if you have one.
Tools
- A mixing glass, or any sturdy glass, for stirring the drink.
- A rocks glass to serve it in.
- A barspoon, a large ice cube, and a peeler.
- A kitchen torch and wood chips or a thin wood plank or coaster, plus a heatproof surface.
- A coaster or small plate to cover the glass. A small cloche works too.
How to make it
- Build the drink. In the mixing glass, stir the syrup and bitters together, add the bourbon and regular ice, and stir 20 to 30 seconds until cold. Set it aside.
- Make the smoke. Set a pinch of wood chips or a small wood plank on a heatproof surface. Light it with the torch until it smolders and smokes. Hold the empty rocks glass upside down over the wood so the smoke fills the glass.
- Trap the smoke. Turn the glass upright and cover it with the coaster, plate, or cloche. Let it sit 10 to 30 seconds so the smoke clings to the inside.
- Pour and finish. Add the large ice cube to the smoked glass and strain the drink over it. Twist the orange peel over the top and drop it in. Serve while the smoke is still on it.
If you have a smoking gun or smoker lid, build the drink in the serving glass, cover it, fill the space with smoke, and let it rest 30 to 60 seconds before lifting the lid.
A note on the fire
You're using an open flame, so work on a heatproof surface in a ventilated spot, keep the torch well away from the bourbon while you pour, and don't lean in and breathe the concentrated smoke. None of this is difficult. It just rewards paying attention for the ten seconds the torch is lit.
Make it your own
- Smoked maple. Use maple syrup as the sweetener for a maple version with woodsmoke on top. Peak fall.
- Switch the wood. Applewood is sweet and mild and leans autumnal, cherry is fruity and gentle, and hickory and oak are bolder and closer to barbecue. The wood changes the character more than you'd expect.
- Smoke the ice instead of the glass. A smoked ice cube releases its smoke slowly as it melts, so the drink gets smokier as you go.
