The maple Old Fashioned is the regular Old Fashioned with one change: maple syrup instead of sugar. That single swap turns a year-round drink into a fall one. Maple brings a warmth and a deep, woodsy sweetness that plain sugar doesn't, and it folds into bourbon like the two were always meant to go together.
The whole thing turns on balance. Maple is sweeter and more assertive than simple syrup, so a maple Old Fashioned goes wrong in exactly one way: too sweet. Keep the maple in check and the bitters sharp, and it's one of the best cold-weather drinks you can make in under two minutes.
Why maple works here
An Old Fashioned is just spirit, sugar, and bitters, so the sweetener is one of three ingredients, not a minor one. Maple steps into the sugar's role and brings flavor with it: caramel, a little vanilla, and a woodsy note that reads as autumn. It's also more flavorful than simple syrup, so you can use a touch less and still taste it.
What you need
Makes one drink.
- 2 oz bourbon. A bold, spice-forward bourbon holds up best, since maple can smother a softer one. (Which bourbon to reach for.)
- 1 to 2 teaspoons real maple syrup, to taste. Start with one. You can always add more, but you can't pull it back out.
- 2 to 3 dashes aromatic bitters. Angostura is the classic. (What bitters do.)
- A large ice cube.
- An orange twist, to finish.
Use real maple syrup, not pancake syrup. Pancake syrup is mostly corn syrup with maple flavoring, and it tastes flat and one-note in a drink. For the deepest flavor, reach for a dark, robust grade, labeled "Grade A Dark Color, Robust Taste" on the shelf (similar to what used to be sold as Grade B). It stands up to bourbon better than the pale, delicate stuff.
Tools
- A rocks glass.
- A barspoon or any long spoon.
- A large ice cube or mold. A big cube melts slowly, so the drink chills without watering down.
- A peeler for the twist.
How to make it
- Combine the maple and bitters. Add the maple syrup and bitters to the glass and give them a quick stir so the syrup loosens up.
- Add the bourbon. Pour it in and stir briefly to bring everything together.
- Add ice and stir. Drop in one large cube and stir for 20 to 30 seconds, until the glass is cold and the drink has opened up a little with the melt.
- Taste, then finish. This is the moment to add a touch more maple if it needs it. Twist the orange peel over the top to spray its oil across the drink, then drop it in.
A drink that tastes a shade too strong at first often lands right once the ice has done its work, so give it the full stir before you reach for more maple.
Make it your own
- Lean into fall with apple bitters. Swap the Angostura for apple bitters, or use a dash of each, and it tastes like a cold night on purpose.
- Smoke it. A maple Old Fashioned takes beautifully to woodsmoke. See the smoked Old Fashioned for how.
- Use rye instead of bourbon. Rye's pepper cuts the maple's sweetness and gives the drink more spine.
- Try different maple grades. A darker grade tastes stronger and more caramelized, and a lighter one is more delicate. Both work, so pick the intensity you want.
