The hot toddy is the simplest warm drink there is: whiskey, honey, lemon, and hot water in a mug. It's what people reach for on a cold night, and a dash of bitters is the easy upgrade that gives it a grown-up, spiced edge.
Let's be straight about the cold-and-flu part, since that's often why people look it up. A hot toddy isn't medicine, and this isn't a remedy. It's a warm drink that's comforting when you're cold. If you're actually sick, see a doctor, not a cocktail.
What you need
Makes one drink.
- 2 oz whiskey (bourbon, Scotch, or rye, see below).
- 1 tablespoon honey, or honey syrup.
- ½ oz fresh lemon juice (about half a lemon).
- 4 to 6 oz hot water, just off the boil.
- A dash of aromatic bitters (optional, for a spiced edge).
- A lemon wheel studded with cloves and a cinnamon stick, to finish.
Tools
- A heatproof mug.
- A kettle.
- A spoon.
How to make it
- Dissolve the honey. Put the honey in the mug with a splash of the hot water and stir until it loosens.
- Add whiskey and lemon. Pour in the whiskey and the lemon juice.
- Top with hot water and stir.
- Finish. Add a dash of bitters, drop in the clove-studded lemon wheel and a cinnamon stick, and drink it warm.
Which spirit to use
- Bourbon is warm and a little sweet, the easy crowd-pleaser.
- Scotch is the traditional choice, with a malty, sometimes smoky depth.
- Rye is spicier and drier.
- Brandy or dark rum both work beautifully, and you can skip the spirit entirely for an alcohol-free honey-and-lemon version that's just as warming.
The cold-weather tradition
The toddy is usually traced back to Scotland a couple of centuries ago, and it's been a winter comfort drink ever since. That's tradition and habit, not a treatment. It's a nice thing to have on a rough night, not a cure for one.
Make it your own
- Hot cider instead of water, which turns it into a spiced apple toddy.
- Steep in ginger or a cinnamon stick for more warmth.
- Use a hot herbal tea as the base instead of plain water.
- A dash of your own apple bitters or aromatic bitters for the spiced edge.
